Leading Through Change When Your Team Didn’t Ask For It

Spread the love

By Dr Ayobami Gideon Babalola • Leadership & Executive Development

Some of the hardest leadership moments are not crises you chose to navigate, but changes imposed from outside — a merger, a new reporting structure, a shift to remote work, a curriculum overhaul mandated from above — that your team never asked for and, in many cases, actively did not want.

Leading through change you personally believe in is difficult enough. Leading through change your team is right to be sceptical about, or that you yourself have reservations about, is a genuinely different challenge, and one most leadership training does not adequately prepare people for.

The Honesty Problem at the Centre of Unwanted Change

The central tension in this situation is this: your team can generally sense whether you actually believe in the change you are asking them to accept. Performed enthusiasm for a change you do not genuinely believe in is almost always detected, and it damages trust more than honest ambivalence would have.

This creates a genuine dilemma. Leaders are often expected to project confidence and alignment with organisational decisions, even ones they had no part in making and may privately question. The answer is not to fake enthusiasm, nor is it to openly undermine the change by voicing every reservation to your team. The answer lies in a specific kind of honest, bounded communication.

Principle 1: Separate “I Understand Why This Is Hard” From “I Disagree With This”

You can validate your team’s difficulty with a change without either performing false enthusiasm or openly criticising a decision you may not be positioned to reverse. “I know this is a significant change, and I understand why it’s frustrating” is honest, validating, and does not require you to either endorse or undermine the decision itself.

What damages trust is pretending the change is not difficult, not disruptive, or not reasonably frustrating — when your team can see plainly that it is all three. Acknowledging the real difficulty, without editorialising on whether the decision was correct, keeps you credible without putting you in open conflict with decisions above your authority to change.

Principle 2: Control What You Can Control, Communicate Honestly About What You Cannot

A significant portion of team anxiety during imposed change comes from ambiguity about what is actually fixed versus what remains genuinely open to input or adjustment. Be explicit and honest about this distinction.

A useful structure for the conversation: “Here’s what is fixed and not up for discussion: [specific list]. Here’s what genuinely remains our decision, as a team, about how we implement this: [specific list]. Let’s focus our energy on the second category.”

This does two things: it prevents the team from expending emotional energy fighting battles that cannot be won, and it gives them genuine agency over the parts of the change that remain within their actual control — which is usually more than it initially appears.

Principle 3: Make Space for Grief, Briefly and Genuinely

Unwanted change, even when it is objectively reasonable from an organisational perspective, often involves a genuine loss for the people experiencing it — a familiar way of working, a valued autonomy, a routine that made sense to them. Leaders who rush past this, moving immediately to “here’s how we implement the new approach,” miss an important step.

A brief, genuine acknowledgment of what is being lost — not a lengthy dwelling on it, but real space for it to be named — tends to accelerate a team’s ability to move forward, rather than prolonging resistance. Teams that feel their loss was never acknowledged tend to relitigate it repeatedly; teams that felt genuinely heard once tend to move forward more readily.

Principle 4: Overcommunicate the “Why,” Even If You Did Not Choose It

Even when you were not the decision-maker behind a change, you are usually in a better position than your team to understand and communicate the actual reasoning behind it. Do this work — genuinely understand the reasoning, even the parts you find unconvincing — and communicate it as clearly and completely as you can.

“I don’t fully understand why either” is sometimes honest and appropriate. But it should be the last resort after genuinely trying to understand and explain the reasoning, not a first response that leaves your team feeling like nobody, including their own leader, understands what is happening to them.

Principle 5: Model the Adjustment You Are Asking For

If you are asking your team to adapt to a new system, structure, or process, visibly struggling with it yourself — in an honest, non-performative way — often builds more trust than appearing to have adapted seamlessly overnight. “I’m still getting used to this too, and here’s what’s helping me” is more credible and more useful than pretending the transition is effortless for you while expecting it to be difficult for everyone else.

What This Does Not Mean

None of this is licence to use your team as a venting outlet for your own frustrations with a decision, nor to subtly signal that you agree the change is a mistake while officially implementing it — both erode your credibility and your team’s trust in different but equally damaging ways. The discipline is holding honest acknowledgment of difficulty and professional implementation of the decision simultaneously, without collapsing into either false enthusiasm or open undermining.

A Personal Example

When JRZP restructured reporting lines in a way I had significant reservations about, I found that naming the difficulty honestly — “I know this changes relationships that have worked well, and I understand the frustration” — while being equally clear about what was fixed and what remained our team’s decision to shape, produced far less lingering resentment than either pretending to be fully enthusiastic or allowing my own reservations to visibly seep into how I led the transition.

Have you had to lead a team through a change you personally had reservations about? I would value hearing how you navigated that tension in the comments.

JRZP LEADERSHIP MASTERCLASS

Leading through organisational change is a core module of the JRZP Leadership Masterclass. Register your interest at drgspeaks.jrzp.org/leadership

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *